ext_79737: (Default)
Auronlu ([identity profile] auronlu.livejournal.com) wrote in [personal profile] auronlu 2006-09-07 09:28 pm (UTC)

The script doesn't tell us about Ginnem's pilgriamge, but the Ultimania guide gives us definite dates (http://boards.gamefaqs.com/gfaqs/genmessage.php?board=2000008&topic=21477330&page=0). However, it contradicts the script in a few places.

Script, date of Chappu's death:

Wakka: "He was with the Crusaders when they fought Sin last year. He didn't make it. I first heard on the day of the tournament."
Tidus: "Oh, so that's why."
Wakka: "I became a guardian to fight Sin, ya?"

Script, date of Father Zuke pilgrimage:

Tidus: "Who was that?"
Lulu: "Until half a year ago, he was a summoner. Wakka and I were his guardians."
Wakka: "It was kind of a short pilgrimage."
Lulu: "He gave up halfway. Here, on this plain. Now, he is a monk at the Bevelle temple. This is my third pilgrimage as a guardian. Father Zuke was my second. And my first, well... It ended here, too."

So, Chappu died about a year ago (game time), then after the tournament Wakka and Lulu went with Zuke, and their pilgrimage ended half a year ago. However, the script never specifies when the Ginnem pilgrimage happened.

Ultimania Guide:

2 years ago
- Yuna begins training as an apprentice summoner.
- Lulu serves as a guardian to Summoner Ginnem, who dies on her pilgrimage. Lulu returns to Besaid.
1 year ago
- Lulu becomes a guardian for Summoner Zuke. Wakka also promises to become Zuke's guardian after the blitzball tournament.
- The Crusaders carry out a daring defense operation of the Djose Shore. Chappu is killed taking part in the battle as a Crusader.
- Lulu and Wakka leave on a pilgrimage as Zuke's guardians.
- (6 months ago) Zuke quits his pilgrimage in the Calm Lands. Lulu and Wakka return to Besaid.

But the script and timeline contradict each other in a few places. First, the guide implies that Wakka agreed to become guardian before the tournament, whereas his comments above suggest he joined Zuke and Lulu to avenge Chappu. Also:

Script, on the deaths of Lulu's and Wakka's parents killed in Sin attack
Wakka: "I don't even remember my parents."
Lulu: "I was five then, so I remember mine a little."

Yet the timeline has Wakka aged 23, Lulu 22. Why can't Wakka remember his parents?


Anyway. According to the guide, Lulu became Guardian when Yuna started her apprenticeship, two years before the game. The more detailed backstory for Lulu written up in that guide says she did so after failing to talk Yuna out of becoming a Summoner. Lulu was trying to shield Yuna from the start -- either by getting to Sin first, or by getting enough training to be able to protect her. Note that Chappu was still alive when Lulu went off on her first pilgrimage -- I am writing a later bit of Resurrection on the assumption that a) Chappu was not pleased when Lulu went with Ginnem and b) he joined the Crusaders after failing to dissuade her from a second pilgrimage (although really, it's just as likely that he joined them before she met Zuke).

Post a comment in response:

This account has disabled anonymous posting.
(will be screened if not validated)
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org